Batch layout comparison
Compare two plate layouts by unit cost, active labour and contribution per occupied printer-hour.
Method and cost boundaries
For each layout: batch cost = production cost + active minutes ÷ 60 × labour rate + other batch costs. Unit cost = batch cost ÷ saleable items. Contribution = items × [price × (1 − fee fraction) − fixed fee] − batch cost. Hourly contribution = batch contribution ÷ expected occupied printer-hours. Production costs and time should already include your chosen failure allowance; the tool does not add another one.
Worked example: a larger plate can earn more per hour
Layout A makes four items over six occupied hours, with $5.48 production cost, 15 active minutes at $20/hour and $3 other batch costs. Unit cost is $3.37. At $8/item, 10% fees and a $0.30 fixed fee/item, batch contribution is $14.12, or $2.35/hour. Layout B makes eight over ten hours, with $9.20 production, 25 active minutes and $6 other costs. Its cost is $2.94/item and contribution is $31.67/batch, or $3.17/hour.
Check the second bottleneck
Layout B also requires 25 active minutes rather than 15. If finishing labour is scarce, compare active minutes per item and the total weekly finishing queue. This model does not predict demand or automatically choose a winner. A layout that loses money should be repriced before you scale it.
Use equivalent inputs
Compare identical product quality and sales prices. Include cooling or changeover time in occupied time if it blocks the printer. Use saleable quantity rather than the number of models arranged in the slicer. For mixed products or partial defects, reconcile costs separately before entering totals.